Comments on: Nobody Wants To Steal, But Videos Are Better With Copywritten Content http://www.jimkukral.com/nobody-wants-to-steal-but-videos-are-better-with-copywritten-content/ Small Business Consultant Fri, 20 Nov 2009 12:45:24 -0600 http://wordpress.org/?v=2.8.4 hourly 1 By: Jonathan Bailey http://www.jimkukral.com/nobody-wants-to-steal-but-videos-are-better-with-copywritten-content/comment-page-1/#comment-4766 Jonathan Bailey Fri, 15 Jun 2007 13:03:09 +0000 http://www.jimkukral.com/nobody-wants-to-steal-but-videos-are-better-with-copywritten-content/#comment-4766 I'll talk more about it on my site later, but to give a preview here, what is inconsistent at YouTube, at least when it comes to copyright issues, is not YouTube's policies, but the detection and enforcement by copyright holders. To use NBC as an example, YouTube only removes clips from NBC that it is told to do so. It is rarely, if ever, proactive. If NBC only reports one clip, that clip gets removed and others stay. Also, if YouTube gets a copyright complaint from someone overstepping copyright law, like with Uri, they usually do remove it though they don't have to. It's cheaper, in their mind, to blindly follow the notices rather than wrestle with potential consequences later. Sadly YouTube's policy is inconsistent but its not really their fault, they can only do what they are told. Now, this only applies to copyright law, I'm not making any comment on their other policies. Those they can take full credit for... I’ll talk more about it on my site later, but to give a preview here, what is inconsistent at YouTube, at least when it comes to copyright issues, is not YouTube’s policies, but the detection and enforcement by copyright holders.

To use NBC as an example, YouTube only removes clips from NBC that it is told to do so. It is rarely, if ever, proactive. If NBC only reports one clip, that clip gets removed and others stay. Also, if YouTube gets a copyright complaint from someone overstepping copyright law, like with Uri, they usually do remove it though they don’t have to. It’s cheaper, in their mind, to blindly follow the notices rather than wrestle with potential consequences later.

Sadly YouTube’s policy is inconsistent but its not really their fault, they can only do what they are told. Now, this only applies to copyright law, I’m not making any comment on their other policies.

Those they can take full credit for…

]]>